Sutter Health canceled a proposed hospital plan in Emeryville, leaving the future of emergency medical care in Berkeley uncertain. The decision has raised questions about where residents will receive emergency care if Sutter Health’s Alta Bates hospital on Ashby Ave. closes, including how the change could affect Berkeley High School students, staff and healthcare programs.
On Wednesday, Oct. 30, 2026, Sutter announced it would no longer pursue plans to build a hospital on its Emeryville property. The proposed facility was expected to replace the services at its Alta Bates campus in Berkeley, which Sutter Health says must close by 2030 to meet state earthquake safety requirements. The original proposal included a 200 bed hospital with an emergency room, labor and delivery services, and intensive care facilities. The company has cited uncertainty surrounding the Emeryville project’s regulatory approval process as a primary reason for abandoning the plans.
Instead, Sutter Health plans to develop outpatient medical facilities in Emeryville while evaluating alternative locations for a future East Bay hospital.
The company has said there will be no immediate changes to patient care at Alta Bates while it pursues options to keep the campus operating until a replacement is built. The potential closure of Alta Bates has created uncertainty about emergency medical access throughout Berkeley, raising questions about what the implications could be for local schools like BHS, when students and staff need emergency care.
Amber Hill, a safety officer at BHS, said the school has already adjusted its emergency procedures to accommodate the changes surrounding Alta Bates. Typically, when a student’s condition exceeds what the BHS Health or Wellness center can treat, staff immediately contact 911, and students requiring hospital care are directed to Children’s Hospital Oakland.
Although Children’s Hospital Oakland is a common destination for BHS student emergencies, the potential closure of Alta Bates could place excess pressure on nearby hospitals, including Children’s Hospital Oakland, as more patients will seek out treatment from the remaining hospitals.
Hill said the school maintains radio communication with the Berkeley Police Department and coordinates with firefighters and paramedics when additional assistance is necessary. So far, she said, the school has not experienced problems with emergency response. However, Hill noted that the school’s proximity to Children’s Hospital Oakland does not guarantee that students will always be able to receive treatment there. Children’s Hospital Oakland recorded 42,686 emergency department visits in 2024, a much greater amount compared with 39,136 at Alta Bates. However, while Children’s Hospital Oakland only has 163, Alta Bates has 339 licensed beds.
“Because we are so close to Children’s Hospital, it might not affect us (BHS) as greatly as another site location,” Hill said, “But if Children’s Hospital, say, is full or they aren’t accepting any emergencies, we would have to be rerouted.”
The possibility of emergency care being further away is also a concern for student athletes. Sam Michel, a BHS junior, said athletes typically rely on the school’s athletic trainer during practices and games but more serious injuries can require transportation to a hospital. Michel identified Children’s Hospital Oakland as a common destination for student athletes requiring emergency treatment. He said the distance to medical facilities matters particularly when an injury requires immediate attention.
“If you break something or it’s a pretty bad hit, you would need to go to the hospital as soon and as fast as possible. So I do have an issue with not having a hospital in proximity,” Michel said.
The potential changes could also affect students preparing for careers in healthcare. Nevaeh Valeriano-McDaniel, a BHS junior in Academy of Medicine and Public Service (AMPS), said students are required to complete 40 hours of internship experience to graduate from AMPS. Local hospitals have traditionally provided opportunities for students to gain practical exposure to the medical field. Valeriano-McDaniel said AMPS students have already encountered difficulties finding hospital placements. Children’s Hospital Oakland is no longer considering students from the program for internships, leaving students dependent on other local institutions, including Sutter Health facilities. The potential loss of another nearby hospital could further limit those opportunities. Valeriano-McDaniel said students have recently received more general volunteer opportunities in place of medical internships. She also identified transportation as an obstacle, particularly for students without driver’s licenses or access to cars.
“Not a lot of people have cars or licenses yet,” Valeriano McDaniel said, “It would probably be difficult to get to further hospitals.” For some students, the changes to the region’s healthcare system have received little attention.
Nico Casher, a BHS junior, expressed concern about the possibility of reduced access to emergency medical services. “Having accessible emergency medical services is essential, especially when unexpected injuries or medical emergencies occur,” Casher said, “If residents have to travel farther to receive treatment, it could make an already difficult situation more complicated.” Casher also said the issue receives insufficient attention from the Berkeley community. He said residents should be better versed about decisions that could affect their access to emergency healthcare.
Sutter Health has maintained that it remains committed to building a new hospital in the East Bay, although it has not selected an alternative location. Meanwhile, BHS continues to follow current emergency procedures. However, the absence of a confirmed replacement hospital creates ambiguity about the region’s future medical infrastructure, including where students and residents will receive emergency and inpatient care once the Alta Bates location eventually closes.