“What are your lunch plans?” is a question many Berkeley High School students regularly hear from or ask their friends. Eating lunch with different people and making unique “lunch plans” each day is a long-established cultural norm at BHS.
Each week, many students find themselves scrambling to find last-minute lunch plans to avoid eating on their own. While BHS’ unique lunch culture serves extroverted students who have friends from a variety of social circles, it’s important to recognize the unnecessary stresses that it causes for students who may be more introverted or who have smaller, close-knit groups of friends.
For over 20 years, BHS has had an open-campus lunch policy, meaning students can leave school campus for the duration of lunch and return to campus in time for their fourth period. The open-campus lunch policy, along with BHS’ plethora of over 100 lunchtime clubs, has opened up opportunities for students to participate in a variety of lunchtime activities. While some students choose to attend lunch clubs or frequent teachers’ lunchtime office hours, hundreds of students flood off campus to eat lunch in a variety of spots, often with different people each day.
While BHS’ “lunch plan” culture comes easily for some, making daily lunch plans can be complicated. The process of scheduling lunch plans requires daily communication and planning to collaborate and find a date that works for both people, or, for a group, sometimes weeks in advance. Some students making daily lunch plans opt to keep a calendar for their lunch dates. To make this process easier, some students will establish a schedule or set up “weekly” lunch plans with their closest friends. Even so, making plans becomes a time-consuming task that many deem unnecessarily frustrating and stressful.
“It’s stressful to have to figure out … I felt a lot of pressure, like you could only have lunch with one person, or you couldn’t just join in on someone’s lunch … and it’s like there were expectations of exactly what lunch plans need to be like,” Chloe Kravetz, a freshman at BHS, said when speaking about her transition to making lunch plans at BHS.
Furthermore, students who cannot make a lunch plan are forced to find other plans, join a friend’s lunch — often known as “crashing” — or eat alone. BHS students have created an unhealthy and harmful stigma around eating lunch alone or crashing someone’s lunch plans. “I’ve never felt comfortable eating alone. It feels like you’re doing something wrong or it’s embarrassing,” Kravetz said.
For some, eating lunch alone is preferred or even necessary to support their mental health and well-being throughout the day. Even so, with BHS’ current lunch culture, these students may feel judged for eating alone as it may appear to go against the unspoken social rules surrounding lunch.
On the other hand, where most schools have designated “friend groups” that eat their lunches together, BHS’ lunch plans offer a unique opportunity for students to deepen friendships with people from their various social circles. BHS sophomore Emilie Gill noted that she enjoys having different lunch plans throughout the week. “I like one-on-one hangouts a lot better than groups. I like being able to talk to people I don’t have classes with a lot. Making lunch plans really works for me,” Gill said.
For students whose classes or busy schedules don’t allow them lots of time to see their friends outside of school, lunchtime is a chance for quality time. Therefore, making a variety of lunch plans and focusing on spending lunchtime with friends one-on-one or in a smaller group setting seems most logical for those students. Gill noted that lunchtime is an opportunity for her to prioritize friendships with people outside of her small learning community.
While eating lunch with one group is compelling and offers predictable security, the various daily lunch plans offer an opportunity for deeper conversation and a wider circle of friends. That being said, lunch culture has the potential to harm students’ well-being by placing unnecessary stress on students to participate and find unique lunch plans. Harmful stigmas around eating lunch alone and crashing a friend’s lunch plans exacerbate the issue. With BHS offering a variety of unique lunchtime activities, students should feel comfortable trying to make the most out of their lunch period, whether that means exploring clubs, going to office hours, or making lunch plans.
Students who lean toward the more extroverted side of the spectrum should be mindful of those around them who may be struggling with this unique system BHS has adopted, as well as the stigmas that are placed on eating alone or preferring not to make daily lunch plans. Additionally, BHS’ lunch culture must lose its rigidity and unspoken etiquette rules. Plans should be flexible and welcome people to “crash.” If BHS hopes to foster a more supportive and inclusive environment around our unique lunch culture, it is important for students to be mindful of how they participate in it and considerate of their peers who may find it more socially taxing.