The Berkeley High Jacket


Newsletter

The best of the Jacket, delivered to your inbox.

News Print
November 20, 2026 Login
Investigative

College admissions create pressure that promotes exaggeration and deception

By Sarah Khan-Akselrod, November 20th, 2026

College admissions have become significantly more competitive in recent years, with acceptance rates at top-tier universities decreasing. According to the Common App, a college application platform utilized by over 1,200 colleges, the amount of applications increased by six percent in the 2025-26 school year compared to the previous year. As competition grows, some students feel pressure to showcase themselves in impressive applications. But this pressure can risk blurring the line between self-promotion and deception on applications. 

For Berkeley High School senior Anabel Orozco, who is applying to around 15 colleges, including several selective universities, the pressure to perform can be overwhelming. “I need to be able to do the best (I can) as possible; I need to be putting in all this work,” Orozco said. 

According to a survey done by the National Association for College Admission Counseling, 76 percent of college applicants said that applying to college was a “decisive moment” in their lives. The pressure many students feel is partially based in fact. In some aspects, the bar for college admissions has risen in recent years. One quantitative measure of college competitiveness is measured by the Grade Point Average (GPA), a number that measures a student’s achievement in their classes. In the 2025-26 school year the top 10 most selective colleges’ admitted pool of students had an average unweighted GPA of 3.85-4.0, according to AdmitOdds. Because of these high expectations, a perfect GPA is now seen as more of a baseline than a differentiator for extremely competitive colleges. 

“I think (college applications have) gotten really competitive and I don’t think it’s particularly good for anybody,” Rea Horgan, a BHS senior said. 

She recalled hearing that students in her parents’ generation could get into selective colleges with GPAs around 3.6 and 3.7, while today’s applicants seem to have weighted GPAs as high as 4.5 or 4.9. 

At the same time, pressure around college applications can be blown out of proportion by unrealistic comparisons and misinformation. This is particularly evident on social media, which 47 percent of high schoolers use to research colleges, according to the 2021 Noel Levitz Survey.

“I feel like all over social media, you see all these people (who) have all these amazing things about themselves,” Horgan said, “I feel like I just also kind of need to find a way to top that and try to show it.”

Orozco described a similar feeling, explaining how it can seem like there is always someone more accomplished. “You want to be the best applicant that you can, but you know that there’s always going to be people out there that are better than you,” Orozco said. 

Because of the pressure generated by social media and the reality of increasing competitiveness, students may believe that even presenting their best selves to colleges may not be enough, leading some to embellish their accomplishments. 

According to Micaela Huang, a BHS senior, embellishment has been accepted as the norm. “Everyone overexaggerates, but that’s just kind of what comes with applications,” Huang said, “You’re basically bragging about yourself.” 

While quantitative measures such as GPA and standardized test scores cannot be falsified, there are other aspects of the application that are harder to verify. For colleges on the Common Application, students are asked to report their high school coursework and grades and list extracurricular activities and responsibilities. 

“People want to kind of beef up (extracurriculars), sometimes make it seem like we did more than we actually did,” Orozco said. 

The Common App also includes a long-form personal statement essay that is submitted to all colleges. Depending on the colleges students apply to, they may also have to write supplemental essays, providing them more opportunities to present their accomplishments and personal experiences. 

With aspects of the application that are less externally verifiable, BHS college counselor Yasmin Navarro draws a strict line between presenting accomplishments favorably and exaggerating them. “If you’re exaggerating, you’re lying,” she said. 

According to a 2023 survey by Intelligent, a college ranking service, 61 percent of current college students admitted to including “untrue information” on their college applications, and 34 percent of those students admitted to writing about “untrue stories” in their essays.

“Caltech has a whole team that verifies the honors or awards or information that students put on their applications,” Navarro said, “It’s easily searchable. If you say, ‘I won state for (something),’ that’s an easy Google search away.”

If a student is found to have misrepresented themselves on their applications, colleges may rescind their admissions offer. “I knew a student ... that lied about some pretty major extracurricular activities, and it resulted in her acceptance being rescinded,” BHS senior Jane Kelly said. 

Kelly explained that the pressure around applications contributed to the student’s dishonesty. “She was very intense about colleges ... I think she applied to (around) 30 colleges,” Kelly said, “I think it was her parents, and she was in circles that were very high pressure.” She added that lying on applications connected to an “underlying issue” about mental health troubles exacerbated by college anxiety.

Artificial intelligence (AI) can also open the door to deception in college essays. According to the Fraud Agreement of the Common App, which is used by over 1,200 colleges to submit applications, passing AI writing as original work is considered plagiarism. Still, about half of college applicants admitted to using AI to brainstorm their essay, and one in five used it to create a first draft, according to a 2024 survey by foundry10, an educational research institution.

Navarro emphasized that deception on college applications can turn out to be worse for the student in the long run. On one hand, the consequences for misrepresentation on college applications can be severe, according to Navarro. She explained that colleges are “starting their own teams of researchers (and) sleuths” to verify information on applications. 

Navarro also advised against using AI to write essays, explaining that AI-generated writing often lacks the personal details and depth that make an essay unique. “AI has a very specific type of tone, and you’re going to notice that it has no details,” she said, “Every sentence that’s in (an essay) should only be unique to you.” 

AI’s “platitudes” are surface-level and do not reveal the depth of introspection colleges are searching for, Navarro continued. Indeed, a 2025 Cornell study found that AI essays are highly generic and easy to detect. Even with the pressure of college applications, and the anxiety that may be generated around them, Navarro emphasized the importance of integrity throughout the process. “We only really have our word,” she wrote in a follow-up email to The Jacket.